{"schema":"AGPO-1/1.1","question":"How did an independently operated agent benefit from AG's preflight evidence?","independently_demonstrated_benefit":false,"headline":"No independently demonstrated benefit yet.","by_ownership":{"first_party":{"decisions":1,"report_events":2,"corrected_decisions":0,"benefit":1,"mistake":0,"neutral":0,"unresolved":0,"unknown":0,"by_result":{"avoided_broken_endpoint":1},"by_verdict":{"do_not_delegate":1},"by_client_type":{"other":1},"by_reporter_claim":{"claimed_integration_hook":1,"participant_report":0},"by_decision_basis_claim":{"ag_evidence":1},"runs_stamped":18,"runs_without_outcome":17,"median_probe_latency_ms":391,"median_reported_overhead_ms":null},"registered_participant":{"decisions":0,"report_events":0,"corrected_decisions":0,"benefit":0,"mistake":0,"neutral":0,"unresolved":0,"unknown":0,"by_result":{},"by_verdict":{},"by_client_type":{},"by_reporter_claim":{"claimed_integration_hook":0,"participant_report":0},"by_decision_basis_claim":{},"runs_stamped":0,"runs_without_outcome":0,"median_probe_latency_ms":null,"median_reported_overhead_ms":null},"heuristic_external":{"decisions":0,"report_events":0,"corrected_decisions":0,"benefit":0,"mistake":0,"neutral":0,"unresolved":0,"unknown":0,"by_result":{},"by_verdict":{},"by_client_type":{},"by_reporter_claim":{"claimed_integration_hook":0,"participant_report":0},"by_decision_basis_claim":{},"runs_stamped":1,"runs_without_outcome":1,"median_probe_latency_ms":0,"median_reported_overhead_ms":null},"propagation_client":{"decisions":0,"report_events":0,"corrected_decisions":0,"benefit":0,"mistake":0,"neutral":0,"unresolved":0,"unknown":0,"by_result":{},"by_verdict":{},"by_client_type":{},"by_reporter_claim":{"claimed_integration_hook":0,"participant_report":0},"by_decision_basis_claim":{},"runs_stamped":0,"runs_without_outcome":0,"median_probe_latency_ms":null,"median_reported_overhead_ms":null},"tooling_or_crawler":{"decisions":0,"report_events":0,"corrected_decisions":0,"benefit":0,"mistake":0,"neutral":0,"unresolved":0,"unknown":0,"by_result":{},"by_verdict":{},"by_client_type":{},"by_reporter_claim":{"claimed_integration_hook":0,"participant_report":0},"by_decision_basis_claim":{},"runs_stamped":1,"runs_without_outcome":1,"median_probe_latency_ms":398,"median_reported_overhead_ms":null},"unknown":{"decisions":0,"report_events":0,"corrected_decisions":0,"benefit":0,"mistake":0,"neutral":0,"unresolved":0,"unknown":0,"by_result":{},"by_verdict":{},"by_client_type":{},"by_reporter_claim":{"claimed_integration_hook":0,"participant_report":0},"by_decision_basis_claim":{},"runs_stamped":1025,"runs_without_outcome":1025,"median_probe_latency_ms":0,"median_reported_overhead_ms":null}},"unjoined_outcome_reports":0,"reading_rules":{"registered_participant":"the SAME registered, non-first-party agent presented its key on the preflight AND the report; the only bucket that can satisfy the objective","heuristic_external":"framework-looking User-Agents on both legs; software identity, NOT operator independence — never a headline","propagation_client":"an AG-distributed client (e.g. the Pi extension) without a participant key","first_party":"AG's own agents, tests and operator — evidence of capability, never of adoption","decisions_vs_report_events":"one decision per preflight_id; repeated identical reports are ignored; a later different report is a correction and the latest is classified","claims":"reporter_kind and decision_basis are the reporter's claims, labelled as such; nothing verifies them","benefit":"requires a warning verdict, a reporter-run direct check confirming the problem, AND a claimed decision basis of ag_evidence/both; AG being right while the agent decided on its own check is not a benefit","scope":"a working call does not contradict identity/payment warnings; a failure AG never claimed to test is failure_out_of_scope; consistent_outcome is not benefit","runs_without_outcome":"UNKNOWN — neither refusal nor success","payment":"irrelevant; the path is free and payment proves nothing"},"rules":[{"when":"not called; direct_check == failure; verdict is a warning; decision_basis in (ag_evidence, both)","result":"avoided_broken_endpoint","checked_by":"reporter's own direct check confirmed a problem AG warned about, and the reporter says AG's evidence drove the decision (a claim)"},{"when":"not called; direct_check == failure; verdict is a warning; decision_basis == own_check","result":"correct_warning_independently_confirmed","checked_by":"AG was right, but the reporter decided on its own check — no benefit attributable to AG"},{"when":"not called; direct_check == failure; verdict is a warning; decision_basis in (other, unknown)","result":"correct_warning_influence_unknown","checked_by":"AG was right; whether it influenced the decision was not reported"},{"when":"not called; direct_check == failure; verdict == no_failed_checks","result":"missed_problem","checked_by":"reporter's own direct check found a problem AG's checks passed"},{"when":"not called; direct_check == success; verdict is a warning; every failed check is one a working call contradicts","result":"unnecessary_refusal","checked_by":"reporter's own direct check succeeded where AG reported reachability/handshake failures"},{"when":"not called; direct_check == success; verdict is a warning; some failed check is identity/payment/evidence","result":"warning_not_contradicted","checked_by":"a working call does not test the check AG failed"},{"when":"not called; direct_check == success; verdict == no_failed_checks","result":"consistent_no_action","checked_by":"AG and the direct check agreed; the agent did not call anyway"},{"when":"not called; direct_check == not_run","result":"counterfactual_unobserved","checked_by":"nothing — the endpoint was never exercised"},{"when":"called; observed == failure; detail maps to a check AG scored as proven","result":"missed_problem","checked_by":"reporter observed a failure in a check AG said passed"},{"when":"called; observed == failure; detail maps to a check AG reported FAILED","result":"evidence_correct_not_followed","checked_by":"reporter observed the failure AG predicted"},{"when":"called; observed == failure; detail maps to a check AG reported UNKNOWN","result":"unknown_check_not_covered","checked_by":"AG said it could not test this; the failure is not a missed problem"},{"when":"called; observed == failure; detail maps to no preflight check","result":"failure_out_of_scope","checked_by":"nothing — the verdict made no claim about this failure"},{"when":"called; observed == success; verdict is a warning; every failed check is one a working call contradicts","result":"unnecessary_refusal","checked_by":"reporter observed success where AG reported reachability/handshake failures"},{"when":"called; observed == success; verdict is a warning; some failed check is identity/payment/evidence","result":"warning_not_contradicted","checked_by":"a working call does not test the check AG failed"},{"when":"called; observed == success; verdict == no_failed_checks","result":"consistent_outcome","checked_by":"the call worked and AG had said the checks passed; this is consistency, not demonstrated benefit"},{"when":"report more than 24h after the evidence","result":"stale_join","checked_by":"nothing — a live probe does not predict the endpoint a day later"},{"when":"observed == unknown, or no rule matched","result":"unknown","checked_by":"nothing"}],"measurement_coverage":{"source":"sqlite_durable","requested_since":null,"event_types":["preflight_run","preflight_outcome"],"actor_key_filter_count":0,"snapshot_events":13665,"history_complete":true,"history_floor":null}}